Should you give back the wallet in Super Mario RPG? If you talk to the various Toads in the Mushroom Kingdom, one will have a special task for you. You will be tasked with finding his wallet. It was stolen by Croco when he ran off to Bandit’s Way. Of course, Mario being the hero, you are probably compelled to do the right thing.
After meeting Mallow, you can talk to the Toad with the blue-spotted head and green shirt to learn of this missing item. Luckily for this Mushroom Kingdom citizen, you are already heading to Bandit’s Way to take down Croco anyway, but should you give back the wallet in Super Mario RPG?
Should you return the Wallet in Super Mario RPG?
The Wallet is obtained as part of the story. The wall is found by beating Croco in Bandit’s Way. Once Croco is beaten, he will drop the wallet for you to pick up. With that taken care of, head back to the Mushroom Kingdom.
When you return to the Mushroom Kingdom, it will be under attack by Shy Guys. Defeat the Shy Guy that is bouncing on the Toad near the first building that is across from the shop and where you get the Signet Ring to find Hidden Treasures.
The Toad here will ask for his wallet back and you can answer with “sure” and “no way.” During this instance, you should give the wallet back. This is the best choice since the Toad will give you a Flower Tab in return. This will get you FP which is far more useful than the alternative.
Should you decide to sell the wallet, you will only get 123 Coins. Considering it is possible to farm coins in the game, this amount is not a lot. As a bonus, the Toad that asked you to grab the wallet will be angry at Mario for the rest of the game. While this won’t negatively impact your game, it isn’t something the hero should do.